How a Fishery Management Dispute Curtailed the Power of Federal Agencies

The Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) announced several major rulings this week, one of which will have serious implications for ocean and environmental policy.

Image: Herring (NOAA Fisheries)

In a 6-3 decision, the justices overturned SCOTUS’ 1984 landmark Chevron v. Natural Resources Defense Council decision, which has informed how courts view agency decisions for the last 40 years. The Chevron decision gave rise to what is commonly called the Chevron doctrine or Chevron deference, which prompts federal courts to defer to a federal agency’s interpretation of an ambiguous law as long as the agency interpretation is deemed reasonable. Under the Chevron doctrine, federal courts apply a two step “test” to agency decisions, considering (1) if Congressional intent is clear and, if not, (2) whether an agency’s rule was reasonably construed and not arbitrary or capricious. (We’d be remiss if we didn’t share this video inspired by the Chevron two step.)

Conservatives have tried for decades to overturn the Chevron decision, arguing that it gives too much power to the executive branch by forcing the courts to defer to agencies. Some arguments also point out that the Chevron doctrine lets Congress purposely pass ambiguous laws and kick the details to the agencies. Supporters of the Chevron doctrine typically argue that agencies have more expertise than judges or Congressional staff and should be the ones to fill in the details of lawmaking. The issue cuts to the core of the question of balance of power between the legislative and executive branches of government.

The court’s decision, announced on Friday, June 28, came from their review of two fishery-related cases: Relentless v. Department of Commerce and Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo. Both cases challenged a NOAA Fisheries rule that requires the herring industry to pay for the costs, estimated at $710 per day, associated with carrying observers on board their vessels to collect data about their catches and monitor for overfishing. Chief Justice John Roberts wrote the majority opinion, which called the Chevron doctrine “misguided because agencies have no special competence in resolving statutory ambiguities. Courts do.” The dissenting opinion, written by Justices Elena Kagan, Sonia Sotomayor, and Ketanji Brown Jackson argues that “agencies are more likely to have the technical and scientific expertise to make such decisions.”

This decision represents a major shift in power. Moving forward, individual judges will be able to more easily overturn agency rules if they disagree with the agency’s interpretation of a given law. We can expect this decision to change rule making at the agency level and lawmaking at the Congressional level. We’ll keep you posted as the implications of this decision unfold.

Brandon Elsner

Brandon Elsner is a government affairs professional with extensive experience shaping federal policy in oceans, science, environment, and infrastructure. He most recently directed federal strategic services at Waggoner Engineering, helping communities secure significant federal funding for water, transportation, and economic development projects. Brandon previously held senior advisory roles at NOAA and the White House Council on Environmental Quality and was a Legislative Assistant for Senator Roger Wicker (R-MS).

FAVORITES

Thai Boba Tea

Orca

Greater DC area

Marianne Brisson

Marianne helps mission-driven organizations scale their impact through streamlined operations, project leadership, and strategic communications. She leads ESP’s day-to-day operations and ensures firm-wide success. Marianne previously served as Policy and Operations Advisor to the Minister of Fisheries, Oceans and the Canadian Coast Guard.

FAVORITES

Hot latte with oatmilk

Nudibranch

Based in Oregon

Monaliza Manalinding

Monaliza has over three years of experience supporting small businesses professionals and managing fast-paced administrative operations. She brings strong skills in client relations, scheduling, and marketing support, ensuring efficient workflows and exceptional service across all facets of the firm.

FAVORITES

Ginger Tea

Sea turtles

Davao City, Philippines

Sarah Keartes

Sarah brings a decade of media relations and science communication expertise to her role at ESP Advisors. Before joining ESP, she reported on marine and coastal science for outlets including National Geographic News, PBS Digital Studios, and Hakai Magazine.

FAVORITES

Iced tea

Scalloped hammerhead

Based in Oregon

Cat Elia

With over a decade of experience bringing clients’ visions to reality, Cat specializes in marketing and brand development. As both a designer and artist, she excels in visual storytelling and graphic strategy.

FAVORITES

Iced coffee with milk

Frog fish

Based on the West Coast

Caroline Roche

Caroline brings sharp policy instincts and a passion for coastal resilience to ESP Advisors. At the White House Council on Environmental Quality, she supported both the freshwater and ocean policy teams. Most recently, she worked on communications and government affairs for Restore America’s Estuaries, deepening her expertise in habitat protection and federal engagement. Caroline holds a dual degree in Political Science and Fine Art from George Washington University.

FAVORITES

Unsweetened Iced Green Tea

Beluga Whale

Based in Washington, DC

Austen Stovall

Austen Stovall’s background is in coral reef ecology, nature-based solutions, and coastal management. She most recently worked for Representative Jared Huffman (D-CA-02) on his oceans and fisheries portfolio. Austen holds a master’s degree in coastal science and policy from UC Santa Cruz.

FAVORITES

Iced oat milk latte with coconut syrup

Corals

Based in DC

Kat Montgomery

Kat draws upon her ocean policy expertise and years of experience managing projects, programs, and teams to catalyze success for ESP Advisors and our clients. Most recently, Kat served as staff for Senator Roger Wicker (R-MS), former Chair of the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation.

FAVORITES

Cappuccino with sugar

Seahorse

Based in Virginia

Emily Patrolia

Emily Patrolia founded ESP Advisors to address the need for sophisticated government and public affairs services in the community she holds dear. Emily uses her advocacy and congressional experience and deep understanding of environmental science to lead the firm in all its endeavors.

FAVORITES

Cappuccino

Yeti crab

Based in DC

tttttttt

We are a small but mighty team working to build a culture that leans into vulnerability, clarity, integrity, and transparency. Open communication, collaboration, and relationship building are of the utmost importance to our team. While our work is hard-charging and relies on exceptional attention to detail and deadline management, we remain dedicated to the wellbeing of our staff. Our goal is to ensure our team members are fulfilled both personally and professionally.

PAMELA DAY TAPSCOTT

Pamela Day has over 25 years of experience on Capitol Hill. As Chief of Staff for the late Congressman Don Young (R-AK), father of many initiatives and laws that govern ocean resources today, Pamela managed the annual appropriations process and oversaw 16 original bills that were signed into law.

FAVORITES

Coffee

Otter

Maryland